That’s right, you read right. Someone has plagiarized one of my reviews. I am sad and highly disappointed to find that my review of Gena Showalter’s Twisted has been plagiarized by a fellow blogger.
To my knowledge, this is the first time that this has happened to me, and I am very stunned, shocked and at a loss of words in how I feel. I literally cannot describe all the feelings going through me. I am of course enraged. We book bloggers put A LOT of work into our sites, especially our reviews. Most of us are reviewing because we love literature and we want to share that with others. I feel as if I have been robbed – robbed of my creativity, honesty, and so much more. I now have a sense of fear that every time I post a review that someone will do the same. I should not have to feel this way at all – none of us should. I understand that we take the risk of these things anytime we post anything online, whether that be reviews, tweets, facebook comments, etc. But at the same time I honestly believed that there was a very high level of respect between Book Bloggers. I don’t believe that every Book Blogger does this, in fact I think that very few do this, or at least I hope so.
Dictionary.com has defined Plagiarism as…
1. the unauthorized use or close imitation of the language and thoughts of another author and the representation of them as one’s own original work, as by not crediting the author: It is said that he plagiarized Thoreau’s plagiarism of a line written by Montaigne. Synonyms: appropriation, infringement, piracy, counterfeiting; theft, borrowing, cribbing, passing off.
2. something used and represented in this manner: Well-respected publishers are developing a sharper eye for plagiarism in submitted manuscripts.
As you can see plagiarism is not just simply coping and pasting something, but also steeling someone’s ideas and thoughts and passing them off as your own.
I have been debating of whether to share the site that plagiarized my review and have finally come to the conclusion that because of the situation, and the severity I feel it has, that I am going to…. Gothical’s Book Review. I have of course politely asked the blogger to take down the review and have expressed my feelings but have yet to hear back. I can’t help but laugh a bit only because the review was so bluntly copied, WORD FOR WORD, except a few minor changes:
Here are the comparisons of my review of Gothical’s:
(mine is green and Gothical’s is in red – – what was added or changed is in blue)
Compared to the two previous novels, Twisted is much darker. At the end of Unraveled the prophecy of Aden’s death has come true, while Victoria attempts to save his life. Mary Ann has just run away to keep her new Drainer powers from killing her friends, most importantly Riley. In Twisted, we find that Aden is alive, but is greatly changed… he is a vampire with an unquenchable thirst for blood, and not just anyone’s blood, but Victoria’s. Riley is on the search for Mary Ann while Victoria is experiencing more and more human qualities…
Compared to the two previous novels, Twisted is much darker, more better but I would say I enjoyed the first two books better. At the end of Unraveled the prophecy of Aden’s death has come true, while Victoria attempts to save his life. Mary Ann has just run away to keep her new Drainer powers from killing her friends, most importantly Riley. In Twisted, we find that Aden is alive, but is greatly changed… he is a vampire with an unquenchable thirst for blood, and not just any one’s blood, but Victoria’s. Riley is on the search for Mary Ann while Victoria is experiencing more and more human qualities…
Most of the book is divided between Aden’s-Victoria’s story and Mary Ann’s-Riley’s story. With Aden’s new Vampire powers, he finds himself uncaring, unfeeling, mean, and ruthless…. almost too much like Vlad (who is still alive), but at times the real Aden resurfaces… or does it? Meanwhile, Mary Ann surges forward to find Aden’s parents and the bodies to match Aden’s souls in an attempt to keep her mind off of Riley. But alas, of course that doesn’t really work.
Most of the book is divided between Aden’s-Victoria’s story and Mary Ann’s-Riley’s story. With Aden’s new Vampire powers, he finds himself uncaring, unfeeling, mean, and ruthless…. almost too much like Vlad (who is still alive), but at times the real Aden resurfaces… or does it? Meanwhile, Mary Ann surges forward to find Aden’s parents and the bodies to match Aden’s souls in an attempt to keep her mind off of Riley. But [alas, of course that – – this was left out] it doesn’t work.
There are many unexpected twists and turns. It is impossible to even come close in guessing what is going to happen next. New characters are introduced, new conflicts are created, and new emotions are felt. My heart fell and rose many times – this book is an emotional roller coaster in all the right ways.
There are many unexpected twists and turns. It is impossible to even come close in guessing what is going to happen next. New characters are introduced, new conflicts are created, and new emotions are felt. My heart fell and rose many times – this book is an emotional roller coaster in all the right ways.
As you can see, only half of a sentence was added and part of another was omitted. Of course one could say that I plagaired Gothical’s review but my review was posted on August 2nd and Gothical’s was posted on the 12th.
In the end THIS SHOULD NOT BE HAPPENING AT ALL. I should not have to feel robbed, violated, afraid, and every other emotion that is coursing through me right now. I take great pride in my site and my reviews and feel cheated in so many ways. Again, I am at a loss of words right now… I guess that is all I can say. We shall see if Gothical removes their plagiarized review and creates their own…
Andrea
Aug 21, 2011 @ 05:21:35
This truly sucks. I am so sorry it happened and it makes me nervous too! I would have hoped that fellow book bloggers would be more respectful.
Laura (All of Everything)
Aug 21, 2011 @ 05:28:03
Oh no 😦 I hate seeing posts like this. It's unfortunate that someone would have to resort to basically stealing your review, your opinions. Hopefully they own up to their mistake. This makes me nervous too, wondering if my reviews could be out somewhere. Good luck.
Naj
Aug 21, 2011 @ 06:29:55
Oh my. Thats terrible. The blogger should really take it down. I can't believe someone would do that and really call it their own. They could have quoted you or something. Gez. I'm so sorry. Everything will go well. I'm sure of it.
Annabell
Aug 21, 2011 @ 14:27:27
This is awful. What is the point of having a blog if you don't enjoy doing it yourself? I don't see any fun in copy/pasting anything. I'm sorry that this has happened to you.
Victoria Zumbrum
Aug 21, 2011 @ 15:13:29
Patricia I am sorry this happen to you. No one should steal anything from anyone. That review was yours and they should have done their own review. Apparently they never read the book. Tore923@aol.com
Jo
Aug 21, 2011 @ 16:09:54
Ok. NOT cool. How did you find out about this? I guess I tend not to worry about this kind of thing (mostly because I don't think many people read my reviews), but also because I tend to think there's a kind of code among book bloggers to not copy someone else's work.Going over and leaving a small comment on that person's blog now.Hopefully, they will issue you an apology and take it down soon.
Amber
Aug 21, 2011 @ 16:14:17
This makes me really angry because there is a comment next to yours on another review where they did THE SAME THING. They stole someone else summary for a review. I'm really sorry to hear about this. It's disrespectful and rude. I hope it works out for you.
aLmYbNeNr
Aug 22, 2011 @ 00:36:00
Hey Patricia,That is rude and horrid and WRONG of that blogger to plagiarize you! I clicked over to that blog to see what was going on but Blogger is informing me that the WHOLE blog has been removed…well, good!AmberThe Musings of ALMYBNENR
Jo
Aug 22, 2011 @ 00:56:04
I just went back to see what Gothical had responded with — and now the blog is marked as "invitation only." Hmmmm…….
Spencer
Aug 22, 2011 @ 03:28:06
Hi, my review was also plagiarized by Gothical's Review. I tweeted out a message about it, and also left a comment on the post where she copied word-for-word my review (and even my opinion!). Since her site is now invite-only, and her twitter handle doesn't exist anymore, I thought you'd like to know that she has a FB page, where I've also written her a comment about taking down my review.https://www.facebook.com/pages/Gothicals-Book-Reviews/168414326553146?sk=wallI've already reported her to Blogger, and am considering warning certain publishers/authors who've provided her with ARCs in the past (I know the book I reviewed is coming out with a sequel, and I certainly wouldn't want her ripping that off either). If you want to discuss this further, feel free to email me or visit my blog. This is the first time anything like this has ever happened to me, and I'm LIVID! I know imitation is the highest form of flattery, but down right copying?! Grrr!
Spencer
Aug 22, 2011 @ 03:34:16
Also, here is her bookblogs profile: http://bookblogs.ning.com/profile/JasmineCall330As well as her (now decommissioned) Goodreads group:http://www.goodreads.com/group/show/49145.Gothical_s_Book_Review_s
Shirley @ My Bookshelf
Aug 22, 2011 @ 04:02:46
That is awful! How did you ever come across it? We do put a lot of love, work and time into our blogs that it is just hateful for someone to rip it off. I'm glad you shared the blog name with us!
Denise Z
Aug 22, 2011 @ 05:55:16
This is just bizarre – I don't get it. The whole point of sharing your review is to share "your own view" I find if I am going to write a review I will steer clear of other posts until I am done, looks like for good reason. I don't want to use someone's words, even if we are of like minds.
aLmYbNeNr
Aug 22, 2011 @ 21:37:51
Well, from her fan page that Spencer so kindly left, I went to her Facebook profile which unfortunately for her but fortunately for us is open. She complains about people accusing her of plagiarism, claiming she didn't do it, and talks about how she had to shut down her Twitter account and get a new one…here ya go!Sucks that her blog is invitation only now…means she'll probably rip off more people…and then how will we find out? Is there anyway to get her kicked off the blog circuit almost for good?
Patricia's Particularity
Aug 22, 2011 @ 22:25:40
Thank you everyone for the support. Even though Gothical's has done the unthinkable I am awed and floored by the support the Book Blogging Community has given me. You guys are the reason I book blog. Much Love everyone!
Spencer
Aug 23, 2011 @ 13:04:24
It's ABSURD what's going on with this — she wrote a note on her FB page saying that she did not copy! I saw your response, and posted my own, linking to a web album I made containing screenshots of her review side-by-side next to mine. I just can't believe how much she's lying and denying the entire thing! She will NOT get away with this!
aLmYbNeNr
Aug 23, 2011 @ 23:08:14
I was going to report her blog now that it is visible again, but you have to be the copyright owner and she (thankfully) hasn't stolen any of my content. I suggest Patricia and Spencer click on the Report Abuse link at the top of her blog and report her if you haven't already.
aLmYbNeNr
Aug 23, 2011 @ 23:18:42
Should probably also report her on Networked Blogs since your reviews are still up there…http://apps.facebook.com/blognetworks/blog/gothicals_book_reviews/
Jo
Aug 24, 2011 @ 01:59:20
Her blog is now up again, with some very interesting content: http://gothicalsbookreviews.blogspot.com/about Copying, and this: "As some of you may know I have been accused of plagiarizing some reviews, I'd like to tell you all this is completely untrue, I have my cousin and many others as witness that this is not true as I have her look over them and also sometimes we make reviews together. There are many opinions out there and I can't help if my opinion is the same as other peoples, But I DID NOT copy ANY reviews, especially word for word. I would also like for the harassment to stop intimidatingly, or police will be notified. Lastly I WILL be re-posting my reviews, and I'd like to thanks my fans that have stood by me, I love you all. I am sorry I took my blog and made it private, it was because I was fixing/editing the reviews that people said I took them and copied and pasted them, Also there were many nasty comments and I was getting emails threatening me to shut down the blog,etc. From now on I will have a group of blogger friends that will proof read and editing all my future posts and will make sure this form of hurtful problem does not happen again. As both parties have been the ones injured. And I AM happy to report it is now resolved. *Happy dance*"Patricia — did she resolve this with you?
aLmYbNeNr
Dec 11, 2011 @ 22:32:56
It happened again to other bloggers: